Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: What If?
Winga
4/3/08 . chapter 1
This is... how things might truly go. How it should really be.

And this is beautifully written version of it.
Tine
1/31/06 . chapter 1
Oh. Oh wow.
wondering why i
9/11/05 . chapter 1
that was good. i would have liked to read more. if there had been more of course. any chance of u making it longer?
thrnbrooke
3/25/04 . chapter 1
Oh. That was heartbreaking. But did the charm take? Does Draco think about it? What happens now? Please continue! I've got to know!
nemo
1/12/04 . chapter 1
All of your storys are so...depressing! Really, I suppose that means you are a good writer but I always get terrible moodswings after I read one of them.
To be honest, I don't think any relationship between Draco and Harry would work out, either, but shouldm't you try out something happy or humourous or something just plain ridiculous just for the fun of it?
I think it's kind of a challange to try something new^.^
Anyway, back to this story; I think this is one of the most realistic ways of a Harry/Draco-pairing. It's somewhat strange, that, while most of J.K.Rowlings characters are portrait so 3-dimensional and human, Draco stays flat and one-sided as some spoiled hated and hating brat. This is even more curious, because he takes such a big role in Harrys life. Still, some of his behaviour just doesn't add up this way; but the only glimpse inside of him was, in my opinion, at the end of book 5.
I don't think that Draco would act like in your storys, I first thought that's what makes me think of your story as special, but it's the insight in the relationship between the two enemys that is making the characters real and gives them depth (at least for me^.^).
I also liked it, that you showed Harrys problems with relationships in "Perfect Potter" (Yes, this is an all-around-review, in case you didn't notice^.^). I don't think he isn't capable of having working relationships with other people but he keeps too much to himself - and there are much things he can't share with others even if he wanted to - because what happens to him seperates him more and more from a normal life. Still, there are people how'd really understand - like Neville Longbottom. Harry isolates himself with this no-one-understands-me feeling like he's used to from home, I suppose...
And I'm rambling here *looks ashamed*
Anyway, what this all is supposed to mean is; Your storys are great and though they depress me I don't regret having read them^.^
Bye, Kira
Goddess Moondragon
10/26/03 . chapter 1
::sigh:: Pirates of the Caribbean! I LOVE that movie! I LOVE this lil ficlet as well! Great work, I'm off to read more of your work.

-Moondragon
phaedradarkwood
10/13/03 . chapter 1
Pirates of the Caribbean Rocks! LOL

I love this! Your stories are always the best! Please keep going with this, it great!
Warrior of the Pen
8/31/03 . chapter 1
hee hee hee someone saw "pirates of the caribbean"
Sumire-chan
8/31/03 . chapter 1
Wow! Very good story. I wish there was a sequel or something.
Adrienne
8/31/03 . chapter 1
Oh, i like this! is this gonna be updated?
fcuking cathy
8/30/03 . chapter 1
omg omg omg thats so good...UPDATE ASAP
Return to Top