Kind of sad. Interesting perspective on the characters. It would be interesting to add a follow up, where either Crowley or Aziraphale are meddling, wiling or miracling, and they kind of get involved in the battle at Hogwarts

Not what I expected from lupin, I admit, but it was a perfect story. You write very well!

Very good. I'm only part way through Good Omens (bit of a lie actually, I'm on page 29 and started it ten minutes ago.)

I do have one question though, Mr. Fell, is that another name Aziraphale goes by or a reference to Stealing Harry (there's a Mr. Fell who buys bibles in that.) I was just a littl confused is all.

I thought for sure I'd reviewed this, and alas! I hadn't! And I read this story, oh gosh, a year ago? I apologise!

This story is incredibly well-written, and the footnotes are fabulous! I love the dry humour-so very much like Gaiman himself-and oh! Remus! My heart breaks for him. Knowing the background and knowing who Sirius is make his mood and his comments even more dark and tragic. You've nailed everything that I think Remus is: proud yet self-deprecating, strong yet vulnerable, and so very, very alone. I've always thought he would be an opportunist, taking whatever he needed in order to survive. I wouldn't have put it past him to steal or lie (well, we know he did that; even if his lies were more of the omission type) if the situation called for it.

I wanted to hit Crowley (would that have made him happy because I wanted to commit assault?), and then you pointed out that Aziraphale hadn't helped Remus either and, oh, I really wanted to hit him! (Which definitely would have made Crowley happy.)

Goodness knows how many HP fics I've read in the past year (hundreds? over a thousand?) but honestly, this one is one of my favourites. It is one of the few I remember very clearly and often. Very, very well done!

He sounded like Aziraphale's ideal customer—hanging around the shop to give the impression that it really was a shop, but never forcing Aziraphale to part with his beloved books

nice discription

Wonderful crossover story!

I like how you presented the characters' motivations...

I hope you write more like this.

(-:

hello,

I must say you have accomplished one of my dearest and improbable dream : a crossover between HP and Good Omens.

I've read a slight Black Books/HP crossover but never this one.

I love it.

I think I've never commented on your fics (mostly because english is not my first langage so I usually don't feel like commenting in order not to disgusts the writer with my poor grammar) but I have to say that I love the way you write and describe the emotions of the characters (I particulary think about the lovers for tonight serie).

About this one, I found your Crowley deliciously Crowley and your Aziraphale sweetly Aziraphale. It was really great.

Thank you for what you write.

Hee!

Very interesting crossover, Crowly's personality was absolutely perfect the way that you wrote him here, it was very in character.

I fell in instant love with your "Lovers for tonight"-stories the moment I first read them years ago. Now I find your latest story involving two characters from this book I recently buyed and thoroughly enjoyed and poor and sweet Remus - pleasant surprise in the late evening. Cheers!

You are one of the top-writers out there in fanfiction-land.

Z.

I really ought to stop rereading things, but what can I say? I'm addicted. As lovely as on lj, my dear. :)