Well I like It!*Jumping up and Down* I that Dean wanted his neck-less back.(He and Cas are my favorite characters in Supernatural)I love Reaper!

GREAT!FIC!

It took me 1/2 way into the story to realize it was SPN/Reaper crossover. XD I loved Reaper when I used to watch it.

I love this little idea of yours. Well written, and it makes perfect sense in both fandoms.

-GDL

i really liked the concept used in this. Wonder if that means that Lilith is working for or against satan in this? Hope you write a sequal

This turned out really good. I like the way the two shows came together. It was just the type of thing I was looking for when I searched for a Reaper and Supernatural Crossover. I had more Dean being the soul in mind but I think this works really well too. I like how it makes Dean coming back more similar to Sam's deal with the Devil.

good! are you planing writinga sequel?

That was beautiful! I loved how you did supernatural in this one. As soon as you brought the necklace in I thought, "Dean's?" But I couldn't think of why Dean wouldn't have it with him, but them telling us Dean was all ready in hell was awesome. Lucifer actually let him out! Wow, that was an absolutely amazing OneShot. *Throws roses*. Great, great job!

I really love how you meshed the two series in a very conceivable scenario with this, not to mention remaining amazingly accurate with the characterization. I'm actually really enjoying Reaper and it was great to see the characters interact with one another, not to mention the hilarious descriptions of SPN Sam & Dean - "catalog models." Actually your general descriptions and adjective usage were fairly impressive, "faces whiter than a nun’s wimple on wash day," painting enough picture for the whole scenario to play like a really good scenario (or better!).

Anyway, the comedy was great, and the reasoning behind Sam Oliver's reaping was great. Azazel was a clever way to link both series. Not to mention it would be interesting if the Devil from Reaper did play a bigger part in Supernatural, he's just too funny.

I really liked this! It was great!

That's a great idea and a great concept - very well written.

love it!

awesome!

You are absolutley right, Reaper ain't so bad! LOL Especially in your capable hands. The CW did do a great disservice to it tho by pitting it against Supernatural's fans.

I only watched parts of one episode and had to check out IMDB to see who was who, aside from Sam whom I knew. I love Tyler Labine and Sock seems like a hoot. That little interaction between Dean and Josie was so funny and I just recently realized Valarie was on the show so I did get the joke there right away and love it.

You drew me into this story from the start. Had to laugh at the description of the necklace and our boys... catalog model and Ken doll... very true, but they can act and that what's counts. I will agree the amulet is kinda ugly if not for the fact that it is draped around that lovely neck.

I loved your take on the Devil and how annoyed he was with his underlings. We always want the PTB to intercede on Dean's behalf. I don't think any of us considered the Devil being the one to help him, but you set it up perfectly and hit the home run. Well done. Brought a smile to my face and makes me want to give Reaper another shot. Of course, if I decide I really like it I'll be annoyed that the CW blew its chance if it gets cancelled.

At least our boys are safe and Dean has his amulet back and Hell doesn't want him... at least yet.

Kudos, great job. Later, B.J.

this was really awsome! i totally love both Supernatural and Reaper and this was a great crossover! hope there'll be others like this!_

I like Reaper and think you did well with all the characters. I'm glad things worked out in the end, even if only for the time being. Anyway, very funny and good job. C:

that was awesome! To tell you the truth, I am starting to really like Reaper as of yesterday's episode. And I could totally see how that could happen. Yeah, they never really mention the Devil in SPN, do they? It was great. And very real to the characters. I love the line 'Before Sammy has a emo-induced coronary.' I was cracking up. I would love to see more Reaper/SPN Xovers. Good job! :D

I really enjoyed this - I only really disliked Reaper when CW put their repeats on Thurs at 9. But that wasn't Reaper's fault, just American Idols, and CW's idiotic upper mgmt, huh? This was delightful, great sense of humor, and nice handling of the boys, all 5 of them? Thanks! Phoebe